How to Choose the Right Storage Shed Material for Durability

Ready to FINALLY build a storage shed that lasts.

Too many homeowners buy a shed then regret their decision down the road because they didn’t realize how important material matters.

They end up with rot. Rust. Bugs. And an overall shed that falls apart.

But it doesn’t have to be that way.

Choosing the right material can provide decades of worry-free storage. In fact, with the global outdoor storage market valued at over $8 billion, manufacturers have been creating better materials than ever.

In this article:

1. Why Material Matters More Than Most Realize
2. Metal vs Wood vs Vinyl vs Plastic Showdown
3. Consider Your Climate Before Buying
4. How to Choose The Right Material For You

Why Material Matters More Than Most Realize

When you’re planning your storage shed set up for your property, the material you choose matters more than most people realize.

You want something that’s durable and long-lasting. But you also want low maintenance and plenty of resistance to the outdoors.

Consider…

The average storage shed should last you 20+ years. But if you buy a shed made with cheap materials for your climate, you could be replacing it in 5-10 years. Talk about a waste of money!

Your material decision affects:

• Longevity – How long your shed will last. Metal sheds can last 25-30 years while some plastic sheds only last 8-10.
• Maintenance costs – How much you pay on upkeep. Wood requires periodic staining and sealing. Vinyl sheds require almost zero maintenance.
• Resistance to mother nature – Things like humidity, rain, sun, etc.
• Resale value – A quality shed can actually increase the value of your home.

Pick the right material and you won’t have to worry about buying another shed any time soon.

Skip the headache and choose wisely!

Metal vs Wood vs Vinyl vs Plastic Showdown

Alright, now it’s time to compare your main storage shed materials. There are pros and cons to each material that you need to consider before buying.

Metal Storage Sheds

Metal sheds are extremely durable. Most manufacturers use galvanized steel or aluminum in their construction and these sheds can last you 25-30 years if taken care of.

They’re also resistant to insects and rot.

Pros:

• Weather resistant (with the right coating)
• Fire resistant
• Insect free
• Extremely durable

Cons:

• Can rust over time
• May have issues with condensation
• Not the most attractive
• One strong enough impact can dent your shed

If you live in an area with frequent pest problems or high fire risk, metal is the best bet. Just ensure you buy quality galvanized steel with rust-resistant coating.

Wood Sheds

Wood is classic for a reason. It just looks right on any property and can last you 10-30 years with proper maintenance.

Pros:

• Gorgeous natural look
• Customizable to your needs
• Nice insulation properties
• Paint it any color you want

Cons:

• Requires periodic staining/sealing
• Susceptible to rot
• Insects will be attracted to it
• More maintenance than other materials

If you plan on keeping up with your shed and live in an area that doesn’t have major pest concerns, wood is a great choice. Just make sure it’s pressure treated wood to increase longevity.

Vinyl / Resin Storage Sheds

Vinyl storage sheds are a great option if you’re looking for low maintenance.

Made from a material known as high-density polyethylene, these vinyl shelters provide excellent weather resistance. According to recent market data, around 38.5% of the market is dominated by steel covered sheds but vinyl sheds are becoming more popular.

Pros:

• Low maintenance
• Does not rust or rot
• Resistant to insects
• Protected against UV rays

Cons:

• Color options are limited
• Not great in extreme cold
• Not as customizable
• Depends on style – some can look cheap

Vinyl is ideal for humid areas that are prone to rot. If you don’t want to have to do any maintenance at all, vinyl is the shed for you.

Plastic Storage Sheds

If you just need a cheap way to store a few things and don’t plan on keeping your shed for more than a decade, go with plastic.

These sheds are lightweight, easy to put together on your own and require very little maintenance. However, they simply don’t last as long as the other materials.

Pros:

• Inexpensive when compared to other materials
• Simple DIY Assembly
• No painting or staining
• Super lightweight

Cons:

• Shorter Lifespan
• Will become brittle with age
• Not as durable
• Can look cheap

Great for temporary storage or if you’re on a strict budget. Just don’t plan on owning your plastic shed for the long haul.

Consider Your Climate Before Buying

Here’s a secret most people don’t think about…

Your local climate plays a huge role in what material you should get.

A shed that works great in Arizona is gonna fall apart in Florida if you don’t choose the right materials. All materials have their strengths and weaknesses.

Hot / Sunny Areas

Metal sheds will get HOT inside during the summer. If you’ll be storing things that can be damaged by heat, lean towards vinyl or wood. Make sure it’s properly ventilated either way. Also look for UV protected materials to prevent fading.

Humid / Rainy Areas

Wood is your worst option in humid areas. If you live somewhere that gets a lot of rain, opt for vinyl or plastic. These materials naturally resist moisture buildup. Just make sure your metal shed is coated against rust.

Cold / Snowy Areas

Snow loads heavy on your roof. If you get a lot of snow where you live, wood is your best bet. Just watch for condensation with metal sheds. Try to avoid plastic sheds that aren’t meant for extreme cold as they can crack.

Near Ocean

Salt air is terrible for untreated metal. If you live close to the ocean, vinyl and quality plastic sheds are your best bet. You can get away with wood if it’s treated with the proper coating to prevent salt damage.

How To Choose The Right Material For You

Now it’s time to pick out the perfect material for your shed.

To make the best decision, ask yourself:

• How much money do I want to spend?
• How much maintenance am I willing to do?
• What’s my climate like?
• Do I care about aesthetics?

If you answered zero for maintenance, metal is the best choice. If you want a pretty shed and don’t mind maintenance, go wood. If you want a balance of both, choose vinyl.

Don’t forget to consider your climate before making the final decision.

Wrapping Up

Don’t stress over picking the right material for your shed.

Metal sheds last the longest at 25-30 years. Wood sheds are the most beautiful, but require maintenance. Vinyl strikes a nice balance of longevity and low maintenance. Plastic is best for on a budget and temporary storage.

Just remember:

Materials matter. Pick one that fits your climate and you’ll enjoy your shed for years to come.

Don’t rush your decision.